Skip to Content
Articles

What Foreign Founders Should Know About U.S. National Security Investment Screenings

For foreign companies looking to enter the U.S. market, whether by opening a U.S. subsidiary or acquiring a U.S. business, national security investment screening is an often-overlooked consideration that can shape deal terms long after the initial launch.
 
The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) reviews certain foreign investments for potential national security risks, and its involvement can affect the timeline and cost of closing a deal.
 
Whether an investment falls within CFIUS’s jurisdiction depends on several factors, including the activities of the U.S. business and the rights and access the foreign investor will receive. Understanding this process early can help you shape both the terms of the deal and the timeline for closing.
Importantly, when a foreign company expands into the United States, future investments, even if received by the foreign parent, will be viewed as indirect investment in the U.S. entity and may implicate CFIUS jurisdiction. 
 
What Is CFIUS?
Chaired by the U.S. Department of the Treasury, CFIUS is a federal interagency committee that reviews certain foreign investments in, and acquisitions of, U.S. businesses to assess their national security implications. CFIUS has jurisdiction to review:
 

  1. Investments that give a foreign investor “control” of a U.S. business; and

  2. Non-controlling investments in “TID U.S. businesses” (i.e., U.S. businesses involved in critical technologies, critical infrastructure or sensitive personal data) if they give the foreign investor board appointment or observer rights, access to material nonpublic technical information, or certain substantive decision-making rights.


Most CFIUS filings are voluntary, but filings are mandatory in two situations:
 

  1. Where a foreign person acquires a 25% or greater interest in a TID U.S. business and the foreign person is 49% or more owned by a foreign government; and

  2. Foreign investments in a TID U.S. business that develops, produces, designs, tests, manufactures or fabricates critical technology that would require U.S. government authorization, such as an export license, to be sent to the foreign investor.


“Critical technologies” include most items listed on the major U.S. export control lists, including defense articles on the United States Munitions List that are controlled by the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), and many dual-use items on the Commerce Control List.
 
Importantly, CFIUS has authority to require companies to agree to certain terms to mitigate national security risks it identifies. In rare cases, CFIUS may also refer a transaction to the President with a recommendation that the deal be blocked, or unwound if it has already closed.
 
Notable Exceptions
There are several means by which companies can limit or delay CFIUS jurisdiction that may be viable for certain transactions. First, loans and other debt transactions are generally not subject to CFIUS jurisdiction, as long as they do not give the lender rights typically associated with an equity investment (e.g., board appointment rights) or control over the borrower. Similarly, CFIUS will not typically treat convertible debt as a covered transaction until conversion is sufficiently imminent, considering factors such as whether conversion is within the investor’s control. Accordingly, where a company urgently needs capital but the investment will require CFIUS review, the parties may be able to close on a convertible loan immediately, undergo CFIUS review, and have the loan convert to equity once CFIUS clears the transaction. Any governance or information rights should be withheld until clearance.
 
Certain investors from “excepted foreign states,” which currently consist of Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United Kingdom, are exempt from mandatory filing requirements and from CFIUS review of non-controlling investments. Whether an investor qualifies as an “excepted investor” is a fact-specific inquiry that looks at, among other things, where the investor and its parents are organized and their principal place of business, and the nationality of its board members and significant owners. It should not be assumed that every investor incorporated in an excepted foreign state automatically qualifies. 
 
Finally, CFIUS provides a safe harbor for investments of 10 percent or less voting interest in a U.S. business that are made solely for the purpose of passive investment. This is generally interpreted to apply to investments that do not convey any control rights or covered investment rights. Such an investment will not be subject to CFIUS jurisdiction.
 
Control and Access Rights
It is important for companies to understand how granting certain rights to foreign investors can affect CFIUS jurisdiction.
 
Consent or veto rights over important business decisions—such as approving the operating budget, declaring dividends, taking on debt, future mergers or acquisitions, or appointing senior management—can meet the CFIUS threshold for control. If you are negotiating a minority stake, it is important to understand that these governance provisions can be sufficient to create CFIUS jurisdiction. A small stake with significant decision-making rights can still give foreign investors control in CFIUS’s view.
 
It is also important for companies to understand whether they are a TID U.S. business, which could cause non-controlling investments to trigger CFIUS jurisdiction if the foreign investor receives:
 

  1. Access to material nonpublic technical information;

  2. A board seat, board observer rights or the right to nominate a director; or

  3. Involvement beyond voting shares in certain substantive business decisions.


These rights deserve attention when negotiating the investment. Board participation and access to technical information can affect the CFIUS analysis even where your equity stake is small.
 
Finally, it is important for companies to understand the export classification of the products and technologies they develop, produce, design, test, manufacture, or fabricate, as this can not only affect the company’s status as a TID U.S. business but also cause CFIUS filings to be mandatory for certain foreign investors.
 
Timeline
CFIUS reviews take time, so companies should plan for them early and build the CFIUS timeline into the overall deal schedule.
There are two filing paths available: a short-form filing (a “Declaration”) and a full joint voluntary notice (JVN).
 
A JVN is subject to a 45-day review period, which CFIUS may extend with a further 45-day investigation period. At the end of the review period (or investigation period, if applicable), CFIUS will either clear the transaction, require the parties to enter into an agreement to mitigate national security concerns, or, in rare cases, refer the matter to the President of the United States with a recommendation that the transaction be blocked.
 
The Declaration has a shorter 30-day review period, but there is a risk that CFIUS is unable to reach a conclusion on the filing at the end of the review period, or it may require the parties to file a full JVN.
 
Key Takeaways
CFIUS considerations are best addressed early, before a term sheet is signed. Founders and foreign investors should assess whether the target is a TID U.S. business, review the governance and information rights being negotiated, and build any required filing into the deal timeline. Experienced counsel can help you determine whether a filing is mandatory or advisable and structure the investment to reduce regulatory risk.

Cookie Policy

This website uses cookies to maximize your experience and help us improve it. To learn more about cookies, how we use them and how to change your cookie settings please view our cookie policy. By using this site you indicate your consent to this.